Chapter 8 - The Lie About the Father

The darkness lasted only three seconds, but it was long enough for the cellar to change.
When Gideon’s emergency light came on, Ethan had vanished. The stairs were empty. The filing cabinets stood open, and the metal box from Pier Nine was gone.
Norah looked at Lucian. “He took the evidence.”
“He took the bait,” Lucian said.
“You knew he would be here?”
“No.”
“Then stop speaking as if you planned this.”
Lucian accepted the rebuke without protest. He pulled her toward the rear exit, but Norah stopped at the sound above them. A chair scraped across the cafe floor. Then Elise spoke again, closer this time.
“He told you the baby was his, didn’t he?”
Norah’s stomach twisted.
Maya whispered, “That’s impossible.”
Elise laughed softly. “Ethan has always confused possession with love.”
Lucian’s face went still. “Norah, look at me.”
She did not. The timeline had been simple in her mind. She and Ethan had been apart for years. She and Lucian had been married for eighteen months. There had never been a question about the baby’s father.
“She’s trying to destabilize you,” Lucian said.
“How would she know?”
“Because she knows what Ethan will say.”
The rear door burst open. A smoke canister rolled across the floor, and Gideon shoved Norah behind a cabinet. Lucian fired once toward the stairwell, then grabbed a fire extinguisher and cleared a path through the smoke.
They escaped through the alley as the cafe alarm shrieked overhead. A black sedan sped away from the curb. Through its rear window, Norah saw a woman in a silver pendant turn her head.
Elise looked directly at her.
Back at the estate, Dr. Ortiz repeated the blood test and ordered a paternity test using Lucian’s sample. Norah sat in the examination room with her arms folded, unable to look at either of them.
“Ethan is lying,” she said.
Lucian sat across from her. “I know.”
“You don’t know that.”
“I do.”
“Because you trust me?”
“Because I remember the night this child was conceived.”
The bluntness of it made her look up. Lucian’s eyes were tired but certain.
“Then why do I feel as if everyone else has a piece of my life except me?” she asked.
He leaned forward. “Because I tried to keep you safe by deciding what you could survive. That was arrogance, not protection.”
Dr. Ortiz returned before Norah could answer. The preliminary result confirmed that Lucian was the biological father.
Relief came first, followed by anger at herself for needing proof. Lucian closed his eyes when the doctor spoke, and Norah saw how deeply the accusation had cut him.
Then Gideon entered with a tablet.
“The photograph Ethan left in the cellar was altered,” he said. “The clinic date is real, but the image was assembled from two separate security captures.”
Norah stood. “Why would Elise use a fake photograph?”
Gideon turned the tablet around. “Because she was not at the clinic with Celia Rane. She was being transferred through it.”
The footage showed Elise being escorted by two men. She looked frightened, not allied. Celia stood nearby, speaking to someone on a phone.
Lucian studied the image. “She is a prisoner.”
“Maybe,” Norah said. “Or maybe she knows how to look like one.”
Maya’s phone buzzed. She read the message and went white.
“It’s from Jonah,” she said. “He says Ethan freed him.”
“Where is he?” Norah asked.
Maya swallowed. “He says he’s with our mother.”
The room went silent.
May you like
Norah’s phone began to ring.
The caller ID displayed her own number.